Skip to main content

Quality Casting

In recent weeks I have stressed the importance of quality writing in soaps, what works and what does not. In this post I want to discuss the importance of quality casting. It sounds simple enough to say that every show needs talented actors in order to stay afloat, but many shows seem to struggle with this, even with the thousands and thousands of out-of-work actors looking for work.

Y&R is certainly a show that I would say struggles with finding talented actors to fill their roles. The only truly great find that Y&R has had in recent months has been Billy Miller (Billy), but technically they did not find him because he was on All My Children first. I would say that Y&R got lucky in casting Billy. He has the right look and is a gifted actor who is believable as an Abbott. Y&R has not been so lucky in finding other talent. Neither of the actresses they have hired to play Eden have been suitable for that role. The first actress (Erin Sanders) seemed too inexperienced to take on that sort of material and the new Eden (Vanessa Marano) just does not fit somehow. However, it is entirely possible that the fault lies within the makeup of the character, a writing flaw. Y&R's casting problems continued when they hired Clementine Ford to play Mac, a role that is just not right for her. First of all she looks too old to have been Billy's high school sweetheart. This was obvious from day one. And even though Y&R has apparently given her hair extensions to try to make her look younger, it is just not working. She has no chemistry with Billy and does not seem to connect with any of the other actors on an emotional level. Then of course, there is Michael Muhney who replaced Chris Engen as Adam a few weeks ago. I know that Y&R had little notice of Engen's departure, but I am sure they auditioned other actors for the Adam role before hiring Engen, so I am surprised that they could not find someone other than Muhney to fill that role. I must reiterate, however, that Y&R's problems are more complex than just poor casting, so I am going to move on to GH, a show that is excelling in finding great talent.


GH is in the middle of aging their younger actors by replacing them with older talent. This is a pitfall for many shows, a task that can either be beneficial or harmful to a show's storylines and overall quality, depending on the actors that are hired. Fortunately for GH they seem to have a brilliant casting department because lately they have hired young actors that not only fit in their roles but seem to be thriving in them. For close to a year fans of the show waited to see if the Michael character would wake up from his coma, a more mature version of his former self. Everyone hated to see Dylan Cash exit the role of Michael, uncertain if another actor would be able to fill his shoes. And while the new Michael, aka Drew Garrett, is completely unlike Cash's Michael, Garrett shines in this role and takes the character to a whole new level. Another great find has been the actress who plays the older Kristina, Lexi Ainsworth. She not only looks every bit like her fictional mother's daughter, and Sam's half-sister, but fits the role so well it is hard to imagine anyone else playing this part. The part of Kristina was soon followed by the casting of her other half sister Molly, played by Haley Alexis Pullos. And while it is too soon to tell what if anything the aging of Molly will bring to GH, Pullos seems capable of holding her own as a young actress and certainly looks the part of Molly. Another recent great find for GH has been the introduction of Olivia and Sonny's son Dante, played by Dominic Zamprogna. Fans have waited for a long time to see who would play Olivia and Sonny's secret love child and so far Zamprogna has not disappointed. He seems to have chemistry with every actor he has shared a scene with and looks exactly like how one would expect Sonny's son to look. He even shares some of Sonny's mannerisms.

These are just recent examples of GH's good fortune in finding the right actors to fill their roles. And unlike other soaps, I have been unable to detect any casting errors on this show for a long time. GH seems to be taking their time with both writing and casting to make sure all of the pieces fit just right before presenting them to the viewers. They seem to realize that quality is more important than quantity of storylines or actors. And in the end this type of patience will pay off for both the viewers and the show.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

All About Mia: DOOL

After months of allowing herself to be deceived and manipulated by Nicole and Stefano so that she could keep her baby's adoption intact, only to find out that said baby wasn't hers because her baby had died, one would think that Mia would have enough drama to last a lifetime. Instead it seems that she has picked up a few bad habits from Nicole because she has turned to manipulating Gabi in order to stake her claim on Chad, someone she didn't seem to want a few weeks ago. As if the Mia character wasn't irritating enough already, this newly calculative Mia is actually making me feel sorry for Gabi, which only makes her that much more irritating. I was stunned that she used Nicole's hearing as an opportunity to drive a wedge between Chad and Gabi, the same hearing that they were discussing her baby's death and the kidnapping of Will's baby sister. In doing this she not only undermined Will's importance in her life, but Sydney and Grace's as well...and p

48th Annual Daytime Emmy Nominations!

The 48th Annual Daytime Emmy Nominees Outstanding Lead Actress Nancy Lee Grahn as Alexis Davis (General Hospital, ABC) Finola Hughes as Anna Devane/Alex Marick (General Hospital, ABC) Melissa Claire Egan as Chelsea Lawson (The Young and the Restless, CBS) Genie Francis as Laura Collins (General Hospital, ABC) Jacqueline MacInnes Wood as Steffy Forrester (The Bold and the Beautiful, CBS)   Outstanding Lead Actor Thorsten Kaye as Ridge Forrester (The Bold and the Beautiful, CBS) Steve Burton as Jason Morgan (General Hospital, ABC) Maurice Benard as Sonny Corinthos (General Hospital, ABC) Wally Kurth as Justin Kiriakis (Days of Our Lives, NBC) Dominic Zamprogna as Dante Falconeri (General Hospital, ABC) Outstanding Supporting Actress Courtney Hope as Sally Spectra (The Bold and the Beautiful, CBS) Carolyn Hennesy as Diane Miller (General Hospital, ABC) Marla Adams as Dina Mergeron (The Young and the Restless, CBS) Tamara Braun as Ava Vitali (Days of Our Lives, NBC) Briana Henry as Jordan

Bad Goodbye: GH

Words cannot express how much I hate the way GH is writing Steve Burton out of the show. I realize his leaving sort of came as a surprise, but in my opinion they could have given him a better send off than the one he is getting. It feels extremely rushed and quite frankly a little convoluted. First of all we have Bernie with his sudden hand-wringing over something that supposedly happened almost a year ago; and he just has to meet Jason on the night he finally reunites with Sam...on the pier no less.  And don't even get me started on how Joe Scully and "Duke Lavery" are involved in all of this. Up until a few months ago Joe was an antiques dealer working in a little known shop that probably wasn't even being used as a front. In addition there is no way Jason would ever allow himself to be shot in the back. He would have looked around the pier to make sure he wasn't walking into an ambush before ever trying to talk to Bernie. However the most upsetting thing about